imageedit_17_5655961494

Making Sustainable Products…Sustainable

Saving the world is great. Saving the world while making money is even better. Here’s how Target and Wal-Mart are doing just that.

Andrew Winston | Winston Eco-Strategies

Andrew Winston

Andrew Winston

For years, the answer to the question “Do people really want to buy more sustainable products?” was a profound “sort of.”

Surveys consistently show that we aspire to buy responsibly, and we even say we’ll pay more for environmental or socially preferable products. But purchase intent does not always translate to real sales, and companies have often struggled to make sustainable products more mainstream.

That seems to be changing. Kate Heiny, who very recently departed as the director of sustainability at Target, told the crowd at this summer’s sizable Sustainable Brands conference that: “With their words and wallets, our customers are asking for more [sustainable products].”

The numbers bear this out: Within Target’s “naturals and organics” category, sales grew 17% last year, four times faster than its total grocery sales. And it’s not just happening at Target.

A new Conference Board study, as CFO magazine reported, reveals some startling growth in greener products at a dozen big companies like Kimberly-Clark, Dow, GE, Siemens, Toshiba, and more.

[Also on Longitudes: Five Ways to Boost Sustainability’s Value Proposition for CFOs]

Success Elements

Pullquote share icon. Share

With their words and wallets, our customers are asking for more sustainable products.

So why are sustainable products surging now?

I’ve been in contact with Heiny and her team at Target over the last year about the program she helped build to drive product innovation and more sales. Our discussions focused on three reinforcing elements.

First, the company painstakingly built its own Sustainable Product Standard.

Working with UL’s Good Guide system, Target scores 7,000 products on a 100-point scale, with 50 points at stake related to the toxicity of ingredients. Additional points are awarded for reduced packaging impacts (can consumers recycle it?) and transparency (that is, sharing all ingredients on the product labels with deductions for things like “fragrance” without the details).

The list of no-no ingredients is long — 1,600 chemicals tracked or regulated by NGOs and governments around the world.

It’s unclear whether Target will really eliminate low-scoring products, but the company has certainly promoted the highest scoring options – and that’s part two of the story.

Under the banner of “Made to Matter,” Target is showcasing good-guy products, including usual suspects like Ben & Jerry’s, Annie’s, Stonyfield, Seventh Generation, and Method, but also some lesser-known players. In total, these brands are projected to reach revenues of $1 billion at Target alone this year.

With this level of topline growth, it’s no wonder that Target wants more options.

This gets us to part 3, an unusual initiative with the company’s arch-rival Walmart to improve the sustainability of the entire personal care value chain.

[Also on Longitudes: Waste Not, Want Not]

Strategic Elements

Pullquote share icon. Share

In total, these brands are projected to reach revenues of $1 billion at Target alone this year.

But in order to understand their unlikely collaboration, it’s important to consider the competitive strategic elements of Target’s approach.

Target has, until recently, lagged Walmart on building its brand around sustainability issues.

For nearly a decade, Walmart has made environmental progress a priority, in word and in deeds. The company has made significant efforts to improve store operations with their impressive energy efficiency work and the purchase of more solar power than any entity in the U.S. besides the military.

For years, the retail giant has also applied imposing pressure on suppliers to reduce and improve packaging, cut carbon, and much more.

While Target has also reduced its impacts and committed to using much more solar power, it always seemed like the company was searching for its unique, brand-appropriate approach to environmental and social issues.

Now Target has clearly focused its attention on consumers. Making sustainable products more accessible is a great fit for Target — after all, the company was dubbed Tar-jay years ago after its many successful forays into making high-end design affordable.

This all isn’t to say that Walmart has sat still on the consumer front — a few months ago it launched an important experiment on walmart.com to highlight mainstream products “made by sustainability leaders,” as they called it.

But by and large, for years, Walmart has taken, in my view, a mainly operational, cost-reducing, brand-fitting approach to sustainability.

Target is, by comparison, focusing much more about the downstream part of the value chain. But of course, for a retailer to provide better products to customers, it has to work with suppliers and, now it seems, even with competitors.

Target and Walmart launched the Personal Care Sustainability Summit last year, and invited the largest players in the $74 billion market for lotions, soaps, and other beauty and grooming products to join them.

I attended the two main meetings thus far, first in Chicago in 2014 and then in Brooklyn earlier this year. In one room, at the behest of the two big guns of retail, sat the largest consumer product, chemical, and fragrance companies.

The collaboration, which the NGO Forum for the Future is managing, has high aspirations.

Pullquote share icon. Share

We can leverage our scale, influence and resources to improve the way products come to market and drive change for our business and society.

They’ve developed ongoing working groups to seek solutions on critical themes like information sharing; agreements on science-based definitions for safety/toxicity on ingredients; and — in the truly unusual part — group R&D across the value chain to develop new, safer classes of chemicals (particularly in preservatives).

Over the last five years, Walmart and Target have increasingly become what I call “de facto regulators” of chemicals through their programs to limit certain ingredients. But now they’re actively pushing the supply chain to invest better options.

When I asked Target why they would go to this much trouble, they saw the big picture.

As Laysha Ward, Target’s EVP and Chief Corporate Social Responsibility Officer said, “We realize that we can leverage our scale, influence and resources to improve the way products come to market and drive transformational change for our business and society.”

But again, it’s not solely a change-the-world discussion – Target is seeing real customer demand. As Heiny put it, “It is quite clear that our guest is asking for these products, which is why we’re having these summits.”

In all, Target’s growing focus on the consumer end of the equation demonstrates some key elements of a modern sustainability strategy, including giving customers options that are not just greener, but better; data-driven analysis and transparency; value chain and systems thinking; and radical collaboration with suppliers and even competitors.

Anytime the giants of an industry really start competing and collaborating on sustainability, it’s a very good development. Let’s hope we consumers continue to play a positive role — we may be key to companies making big, important changes. goldbrown2

(This post first appeared at HBR.org.)

andrew winston sepia
Andrew Winston is founder of Winston Eco-Strategies and a globally recognized expert on how companies can navigate and profit from the world’s biggest environmental and social challenges. He is the author of the The Big Pivot and co-wrote the international bestseller Green to Gold. http://www.andrewwinston.com

Click the RSS icon to subscribe to future articles by this author. RSS Feed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s